I`ve posted this already in a thread ( with the question if all games that got a ten deserve it ), but i want to know your opinions on the subject! ( and please, let it not be some fanboyisch discussion and maybe with some guy`s that are longer here then yesterday ). And it`s not because it`s PS3 game that i got my doubts about it, but because two tens in a month is silly! If gears of war 2 get`s a ten, i wouldn`t agree either! ( if it`s not revolutionary ).
Okay, this is the first time i ever post at gamespot, but i have been keeping up with system wars for about five years. ( Not to be amused with these little gamewars among gamers , but for this is a great place to get information about games really fast! )
I think OOT deserves his 10 out of 10 score completely! I just started playing GTA V … the other ones i never played! But let me get back at OOT! Gamespot`s review, among others, called OOT flawless ( for it`s time, it was IMO ). For doubters i quote ` Ocarina of time definitely follows in the footsteps of the previous games, and the result is a game that can`t be called anything other then flawless ` and ` In a word, perfect. To call it anything else would be a bald-faced lie. `
The controls were perfect, the sound was perfect, the world was, back in that day, really brought to life with an awsome story! It was a game that was revolutionary! Even for it`s graphics … From the review: graphically, ocarina of time is simply unmatched! EVEYTHING was the best for it`s time!
Now, lets get back to todays standards! GTA V and MGS V! Beautifull crafted awsome games… i will never play the last so, even i`m in xbox360`s favor, i can`t really judge for myself! But do they both have perfect controls? very good, but not perfect! perfect graphics, the best for it`s time ? no …. ( and 20 min. loadtime is just too much ) revolutionary ? no… inspiring? yes, in some places! It only think games that really offer a so called ` best in everything experience` deserve a ten! For example, one of my favorite games ever ` halo: CE `. It did everything so well, but it wasn`t revolutionary! it was a 10 out of 10 experience for me, but in the world of gaming, it`s not ( as it should be )!
That`s wat happened, reviewers enjoy games like a 10/10 experience, and they judge it that way … without thinking if there`s more behind that experience! But in gamespots case, they can`t give MGS V and GTA V a 9.9 or 9.8 … with there stupid review system… we`ll never now if they were REAL 10`s! The scoringsystem here invites the reviewer to give a ten quicker then before! Let me explain: Halo 3, world in conflict, SSBB, crysis, super mario galaxy, the orange box … all 9.5! (ironicly, i thought back then that gamespot was giving away to much high scores :roll
But if you then play one game that is a little bit better, A reviewer is forced to give a ten, there`s no way out! Gamespot couldn`t give al games a 9.5 here! so they have to give more … that is indirecly lowering you`re standards IMO.
But for me a 10 is a game that gives you a 10/10 experience in a perfect way, and more!